Ultrasonics Reviewer's Form


Title of the manuscript:
. . Manuscript Number: . . Date Received:
Author(s):

Please select the name of the Ultrasonics Associate Editor who is overseeing the review of this manuscript:
A G Every
S Hirsekorn
P Lewin
P Nagy
G ter Haar
S Ueha
W Sachse

Please enter your name:
and your full E-mail address: Want a copy? Yes

To complete this form, simply "click" on the appropriate box and type-in your remarks/evaluation. (Cursor, delete keys, etc. are operative. The boxes expand to accept everything you enter.)


Review of Manuscript Contents:

  1. Does the manuscript contain sufficient new, original and significant material to warrant publication in the journal Ultrasonics ?

  2. Are the background materials and results properly presented?

  3. Please specify any doubtful or controversial arguments.
    Are there any errors in logic or mathematical analysis.

Review of Manuscript Format:

  1. Is the manuscript written concisely and in good English?
    If not, please indicate suggested revisions.

  2. Should the manuscript be reduced in length?
    If so, please suggest possible cuts.

  3. Are the References reasonably complete?
    If not, please indicate suggested additions/deletions.

  4. Are the figures and tables as well as their captions clear?
    If not, please indicate suggested revisions.

  5. Any other comments on this manuscript that should be conveyed to the author(s)?


Recommended Disposition of the Manuscript:

  1. The manuscript should be accepted for publication in its present form.
  2. The manuscript should be rejected.
  3. The manuscript should be returned to the author(s) for revisions. After changes have been made by the author(s), the manuscript should be accept ed without further review by you.
  4. After changes have been made by the author(s), the manuscript should be returned to you for evaluation and proper disposition of the manuscript.
  5. The manuscript should be reviewed by an additional or another reviewer.
    Suggested reviewer (please supply address, if possible):


The authors, readers and editors of the journal Ultrasonics are grateful to you for your careful and critical review and evaluation of this manuscript. We appreciate the time you have taken from your busy schedule to do this task. Thank you!
Would you like to be sent a confirmation copy of your review? Yes . . . Not necessary

Action :


Return to Ultrasonics Home Page
Version: April 2, 2004